🔭 2024 Feb 9
Ever since it opened its giant infrared eye on the cosmos after its December 2021 launch, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has found a shocking surfeit of bright galaxies that stretch back to the very early universe. Imagine visiting a foreign land and finding that many of its toddlers weighed as much as teenagers. You might have questions, too: Is the cause of such large children something in the water, or might it instead be that your grasp of human growth is fundamentally flawed? Scientists dubbed these relatively older systems ultramassive galaxies and kept scratching their heads: neither set of galaxies could be wholly explained by our current models.
Investigating some of these early galaxies, several studies now point more toward an astrophysical explanation for the unexpected girth—such as earlier-forming black holes or bursts of star formation—rather than some physics-shattering result.
Today in the journal Physical Review Letters, Nashwan Sabti of Johns Hopkins University (JHU) and his colleagues have proposed a solution for JWST's ultramassive galaxies. Existing data from Hubble's UV observations allowed the researchers to better gauge the rates of star formation—the change in stellar mass over time—versus the stellar mass itself from JWST, which primarily observes in infrared. Comparing those two pieces of information, Sabti and his colleagues found that the galaxies were growing exactly as expected in accordance with our cosmological model of the universe: the Lambda Cold Dark Matter (Lambda-CDM) model.
Boylan-Kolchin says the paper makes a “great point” in comparing Hubble and JWST data from this period of the universe. He isn't completely convinced just yet, however. “I don't think the case is airtight,” he says. “The loophole is: you're not necessarily observing the same galaxies with JWST and Hubble. Galaxies can be luminous [in infrared] for JWST but invisible for Hubble. If the most massive ones happen to be in that [infrared] regime, then maybe Hubble wouldn't be seeing them.”